The Creed That Won Corinth (1 Cor 15)

Before we pull the pin: what follows is the earliest surviving proclamation of Jesus’ resurrection in the New Testament. Most scholars agree Paul is quoting a pre-Pauline creed—something he “received” and then “handed on”—that likely crystallized within a few years of Jesus’ death (the letter itself lands around 54–55 CE). The parallel lines, the repeated refrain “in accordance with the scriptures,” and the tight roll call all scream fixed formula. Paul transmits it and (with a deft editorial move) frames himself into it with the same vocabulary used for the others. That’s the scholarly baseline; now we lay the text down and cut it open.

“For I handed on to you as of first importance what I in turn had received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the scriptures,
and that he was buried, and that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the scriptures,
and that he appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve.
Then he appeared to more than five hundred brothers and sisters at one time, most of whom are still alive, though some have died.
Then he appeared to James, then to all the apostles.
Last of all, as to one untimely born, he appeared also to me.”
—1 Corinthians 15:3–8 (NRSVUE)

TL;DR: 1 Corinthians 15:3–8 is the earliest preserved resurrection proclamation—a pre-Pauline creed Paul “received” and then weaponized in Corinth. Its timeline is scripture-shaped, not memory-shaped (“on the third day in accordance with the scriptures”); its core claim is theology, not reportage (“died for our sins”). The verb ōphthē (“appeared”) levels all “sightings”—Cephas, the Twelve, the 500, James, and Paul—into visionary experiences, while the brand label “the Twelve” and the omission of the women signal authority politics, not biography. No empty tomb, no details—just a creed optimized for persuasion. Early? Yes. Transparent? No. And it still leaves Paul as the architect who codified the church’s resurrection theology.█

You want the truth under the church polish? Good. This isn’t a diary from men with fish breath and sand in their sandals; it’s a preloaded creed Paul slaps on the table to win a brawl in Corinth. He’s not chronicling history; he’s wielding leverage. “You deny resurrection? Then Christ wasn’t raised. But he was—so shut it and line up.” The passage is a sermon nugget with a pedigree, optimized for authority, not transparency.

Paul opens with “I handed on what I received.” That’s code for reciting a fixed formula, not narrating a scene he witnessed. The engine of the creed is theology, not reportage. “Christ died for our sins” is not something anyone at Golgotha could have observed with their eyeballs; it’s meaning poured onto a death after the fact. “He was buried” is the ancient way of saying, “Yes, the man was actually dead.” No names. No place. No women. No empty tomb. Just checkboxes.

Then the timeline: “raised on the third day in accordance with the scriptures.” That clock doesn’t come from memory; it comes from a template—Hosea’s “after two days… on the third he will raise us,” Jonah’s belly-of-the-beast motif, the apocalyptic habit where suffering flips to vindication right on prophetic schedule. This is not a stopwatch; it’s a stencil. The creed is retrofitting, not recovering.

Now the appearances. The Greek hinge here is ὤφθη (ōphthē)—“he appeared / was seen.” That’s the stock verb for revelations and theophanies. Paul applies the same verb without discrimination: Cephas, “the Twelve,” the five hundred, James, “all the apostles,” and Paul himself. No special carve-out, no “but mine was just a vision while theirs were brunch with a reanimated corpse.” He files them all in the same drawer. If Paul’s encounter was visionary—and by his own telling it was—then the grammar drags the rest into the same category. You don’t get to smuggle in breakfast on the beach from a later Gospel and pretend Paul left you a trail of greasy fish wrappers.

“The Twelve.” Cute. Judas is gone, but the title marches on. Because it’s a brand, not a headcount. That’s how you know you’re hearing a set piece: the fixed phrase remains even when reality doesn’t perfectly fit. And where are the women—those “first at the tomb” heroes the later Gospels elevate? Vanished. The creed centers male authority: Cephas, James, the inner ring. That’s not neutral tectonics; that’s ecclesial gravity doing what it always does: put the keys in the hands of the usual suspects. (NRSVUE’s inclusive “brothers and sisters” only underlines that women could have been named—and still weren’t.)

The fabled five hundred? Only here, only now, with no names, dates, or coordinates. Paul throws in the chest-thump—“most are still alive, though some have died”—like an ancient “go fact-check me,” knowing full well nobody in Corinth is booking a Mediterranean tour to interview a stadium crowd of unnamed believers. If five hundred truly anchored the tradition, you’d see at least a ripple elsewhere. What you get is silence.

Then James, strategically dropped in like a thunderbolt. Not a story, just a credential: he “appeared… to James”—hence pillar status. After that comes “all the apostles,” widening the circle until the floor stops creaking under the weight of appeal to authority. And finally Paul, “as to one untimely born”—a soft gloss on the Greek ektrōma (miscarriage/premature birth). The point of the self-burn isn’t humility; it’s category control. He locks all the “appearances” into one conceptual bucket, his included.

And this sits inside the same chapter where Paul insists resurrection yields a σῶμα πνευματικόν—a spiritualized, transformed body—not a cadaver lumbering out of a tomb for show-and-tell. His imagery is seed → plant, dishonor → glory, perishable → imperishable, and he hammers, “flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God.” Drag a later, hyper-physical Easter pageant back onto this creed and you make Paul contradict Paul. He’s not hawking forensic continuity; he’s preaching eschatological metamorphosis.

Early doesn’t mean transparent, and it doesn’t dethrone Paul’s influence. Yes, this creed is early—probably earlier than our Gospels—but look at what’s already baked in: “for our sins,” “in accordance with the scriptures,” the brand power of “the Twelve,” the authority roll culminating in Paul himself, and the transformation-over-resuscitation framework laid out in the same chapter. Whether Paul minted every line or curated and polished a hand-me-down, he’s the one who canonizes the theology: cross as atoning event, resurrection as new-creation transformation, Adam/Christ typology, justification and “in Christ” language—the scaffolding of later Christian dogma. The creed may be early; the theology is already Pauline, and it’s Paul’s pen that made it the church’s backbone.

Believe it if you want; that’s your lane. But don’t pretend this is courtroom-grade history. It’s a creed—powerful, pointed, and built for persuasion. Monday’s questions still stand when Sunday’s recitation ends.

—

Sources / Further Reading

• NRSV Updated Edition (NRSVUE). National Council of Churches, 2021–22.

• James D. G. Dunn, Jesus Remembered (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2003).

• Larry W. Hurtado, Lord Jesus Christ: Devotion to Jesus in Earliest Christianity (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2003).

• Dale C. Allison Jr., Resurrecting Jesus: The Earliest Christian Tradition and Its Interpreters (London: T&T Clark, 2005).

• Bart D. Ehrman, How Jesus Became God (San Francisco: HarperOne, 2014).

• N. T. Wright, The Resurrection of the Son of God (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2003).

• (Web) Bible Odyssey (Society of Biblical Literature): “Resurrection” and “The Crucifixion in Paul”

• (Web) Perseus Digital Library: LSJ entry for ὁράω

• (Web) 1 Corinthians 15 (NRSVUE), full-chapter context (Bible Gateway)